These PROOF files are NOT open to public or the SOS forum membership to exmaine for themselves!
NOTE:
PDF files archive 'Ayatollagondola' wrote:
These are the PDF files for the case. You can click on the attachments on this post to either save or open them.
Court_minutes_Gilchrist[1].pdf (366.9 KB, 0 views)
SOS-Chelene-Gilchrist Press_Release_Court_Ruling[1].pdf (78.1 KB, 0 views)
Stipulation_for_Gilchrist[1].pdf (12.8 KB, 1 views)
***-SENT From My SOS friend~ I wanted to read the court minutes for myself on the SOS forums. I tried to access these PDF file on the SOS forums as a genral member. They are locked-up from general members, maybe only AdMs can access them. That probably accounts for the ZERO views and only ONE view for the final stipulation.
WHY WOULD THEY DO THAT IF THEY ARE IN THE RIGHT?
Below is copy and pasted the thread posting propaganda from the SOS forums in their exact forum content and order.
=
Chelene 'Patriotic Dream' Nightengale posts-
1-10-09 PD- Official Court Documents (Gilchrist/Eichler False Lawsuits)
First, Happy New Year Everyone!!!
I know 2009 may not seem hopeful with an illegal alien about ready to take the highest office in the USA, but Americans are finally starting to wake-up!!! http://news.aol.com/political-machin...h-certificate/
Now onto business. I sent a final email regarding Gilchrist drama last year after winning the false lawsuits against me. One would think that the losses in court for Gilchrist and Eichler would have silenced them from further false attacks against patriots. Unfortunately yesterday, a friend forwarded me Gilchrist's latest outrageous lies (see below).
After consulting with my attorney, I am forwarding what I hope will be the final email on this subject! I am not forwarding to benefit those who are already wide awake to the drama created by Gilchrist and associates, but forwarding for the benefit of those who reside outside California and still think Gilchrist is some kind of "hero" so continue to donate to him.
Please find attached OFFICIAL court minutes so that each of you can read what the judges stated. (Eichler and Gilchrist did NOT lose due to being "public figures", they lost because their cases had NO merit!!! Although both are public figures, they filed false claims plain and simple!! Even if they had lost due to their "public status", then anti-SLAPP motions would not have been granted had the claims by them been true.) The attachments are in PDF (readable file only) so that they can not be edited!!
In regard to their attorneys' "due diligence", their attorney Catherine Lukehart worked very hard and even attempted to file settlements on her clients' behalf. She was a worthy attorney! Their first attorney was not fired! (The judge mentioned this during court.) Their first attorney allegedly found himself in some type of legal trouble and could not continue the case.
Finally, and most importantly, neither myself nor Save Our State are receiving money from Jim Gilchrist or Steve Eichler!! All checks are made payable to the lawfirm (please see attached files for proof). The fees ordered by the court only cover legal costs!!! A small amount is being reimbursed to me for out-of-pocket legal fees (court filings, etc..) and the remaining fees go directly to the law office to reimburse them for their legal services. There was no EXTRA money won in these cases! The anti-SLAPP motion was just to cover all the legal costs endured due to Gilchrist and Eichler FALSELY suing us patriots!! (If Gilchrist does not like paying the legal costs, then perhaps he should not have FALSELY sued patriots!!) By the way, I wonder who is really paying the court fees?? Donations to the MMP?
May this email and court documents help to awaken those who donate their hard earned money!!! Be careful who you trust!! And don't let those who instigate drama interfere with the real agenda..SAVING AMERICA!!!!! AND FREEING RAMOS & COMPEAN!!! Stay focused!! DONATE DIRECTLY TO MONICA RAMOS & PATTY COMPEAN!!!!
Thank you!! And sorry to burden everyone!! My goal is to inform in order to save others and prevent further damage!!
God Forgive America,
Chelene Nightingale
Managing Director
www.saveourstate.org
rom: Century21Minuteman
Subject: GIlchrist continues to pay over $1,000 per month to SOS's Chelene Nightingale
To: "Century21Minuteman"
Date: Friday, January 9, 2009, 11:27 AM
MMP funding SOS?
Just made my second monthly payment for Chelene Nightingale of about $1100.
Because the court considers me a "public figure" I am not entitled to sue anyone who deliberately lies about me or the MMP. Our former lawyer (has been fired) did not do his due diligence and left me with a court penalty (payable to defamation defendant Nightingale). I hope she is using that $1,000 plus per month to help her SOS organization solve the issue of illegal immigration. Nightingale will get about $15,000 before the payments are finished.
Please do not try to comprehend our judicial system. It is a shambles in many areas. Only in America can someone publicly broadcast defaming lies about another person or an organization, even knowing those claims to be outright lies or propaganda, and then win a mini-jackpot if the person whose reputation you have damaged sues you for relief in the US court system. Go figure!
But, in my opinion, assuming that the recipient uses his or her unjust enrichment to help solve the illegal immigration issue by perhaps spending all of that money on members of SOS or other immigration law enforcement advocates, then the money paid and received will not be all for waste.
However, some good news came in this week. The same judge fined Marvin Stewart and Deborah Courtney a total of $ 2,182 for penalties for offenses to the court. Stewart has 10 days to pay Jim Gilchrist’s MMP that money or face contempt of court. Counsel for MMP says at least about $26,000 of penalty payments for the benefit of JGMMP are still forth coming. MMP is getting penalty payments from the hijackers / defendants because of their abuse of the legal system. These funds will be used for supporting the MMP continued awareness program about the illegal alien dilemma.
I sincerely wish the best to Mr. Stewart, his close friends Ms. Nightingale, and Ms. Courtney, in any possible future endeavors to help solve the issue of chaotic illegal immigration. I pray that any money they have made, and any time they have available, will be used tirelessly to saving the USA from the Trojan horse invasion we have experienced for the past four decades.
Sadly, all of this money spent in the legal process has certainly caused a halt in the influence of immigration law enforcement advocates all across the country. With so much acrimony among some of the participants in this movement, like William Gheen of ALIPAC, Jeff Schwilk of SDMM, Barbara Coe of CCIR, the now defunct Immigration Watchdog (Brook Young) and defunct Mountain Minutemen (Robert ‘Lil Dog Crooks) it was not a surprise that neither McCain nor Obama gave the slightest attention to the critical issue of illegal immigration during their presidential campaigns.
By the way, next stop: Harvard Law School. I have been invited to speak at Harvard Law School in Cambridge, Ma. On February 26. Harvard also has asked that I write an article (about 20,000 words) on immigration for publication in its esteemed Journal of Legislation.
Despite setbacks, we are still incrementally taking more ground on this issue. We are piercing the intellectual barriers against free speech that have been built around our universities and schools for the past four decades, and the minuteman/woman movement is now becoming a recognized influential authority in the immigration debate.
Thank you all for your support.
Jim Gilchrist, BAJ, BSBA, MBA, CPA - Founder and President, -The Minuteman Project, Inc.
===
spin-off thread of original court cases aaginst SOS
http://www.saveourstate.org/vforums/showthread.php?t=41686
===
SUPERIOR COURT OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
COUNTY OF ORANGE – CENTRAL JUSTICE CENTER
PAYNE & FEARS LLP
ATTORNEYS AT LAW 4 PARK PLAZA, SUITE 1100 IRVINE, CA 92614 (949) 851-1100
JIM GILCHRIST, an individual,
Plaintiff,
v.
MARVIN L. STEWART, an individual;
DEBORAH ANN PETERSON, a.k.a.
DEBORAH ANN COURTNEY, an individual;
BARBARA COE, an individual; PAUL
SIELSKI, an individual; BROOK YOUNG, an
individual; CHELENE NIGHTENGALE, an
individual; and DOES 1 - 100, inclusive,
Defendants.
CASE NO. 30-2008-00105431
STIPULATION
Date Action Filed: April 16, 2008Trial Date: None Set
Plaintiff Jim Gilchrist, by and through his counsel, Catherine F. Lukehart, and
Defendant Chelene Nightingale, by and through her counsel, Daniel F. Lula, hereby agree and stipulate as follows:
The Judgment entered on December 5, 2008 in favor of Defendant Chelene
Nightingale and against Plaintiff Jim Gilchrist in the amount of $10,426.88 shall bear simple interest at the rate of eight percent (8%) per annum provided that Plaintiff Jim Gilchrist makes and continues to timely make monthly payments of one thousand dollars ($1,000.00) to Defendant Chelene Nightingale’s counsel until the Judgment and accrued interest are fully satisfied, as follows:
STIPULATION
PAYNE & FEARS LLP
ATTORNEYS AT LAW 4 PARK PLAZA, SUITE 1100 IRVINE, CA 92614 (949) 851-1100
1. The first payment shall be made within two (2) business days after the
signing of this Stipulation;
2. Future payments shall be made on the first of each month commencing with
January 1, 2009, or on the first business day of the month if the first calendar day is not a business day;
3. All payments shall be made by check or money order payable to "Payne &
Fears LLP" and delivered to Daniel F. Lula, Payne & Fears LLP, 4 Park Plaza, Suite 1100, Irvine,
CA 92614.
4. All payments shall be applied first to accrued interest and then to principal.
5. If, any time, Plaintiff Jim Gilchrist fails to abide by these conditions, either
through non-payment or late payment, this Stipulation shall cease to be operative and the Judgment shall bear interest at the statutory rate of ten percent (10%) per annum, retroactive to the date of entry of judgment.
6. Nothing in this Stipulation is or shall be construed to be a waiver of any
rights or remedies on the part of Defendant Chelene Nightingale, who expressly reserves her right to all legal means to enforce the Judgment.
7. Nothing in this Stipulation is or shall be construed as an assumption by Jim
Gilchrist or Jim Gilchrist’s Minuteman Project, Inc., of any judgment which may be entered against Stephen Eichler and in favor of Defendant Chelene Nightingale.
DATED: December 12, 2008 PAYNE & FEARS LLP
By:
DANIEL F. LULA
Attorneys for DefendantCHELENE NIGHTINGALE
-2-
STIPULATION
PAYNE & FEARS LLP
DATED: December 12, 2008 LAW OFFICES OF CATHERINE F. LUKEHART
DATED: December 12, 2008
By:
CATHERINE F. LUKEHART
Attorneys for PlaintiffJIM GILCHRIST
By:
CHELENE NIGHTINGALE
-3-
STIPULATION
=
Official Legal Press Release
News from SAVE OUR STATE
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE
Contact:
Chelene Nightingale
Managing Director
Daniel F. Lula, Esq.
Payne & Fears LLP
(949) 851-1100
Save Our State Director Chelene Nightingale Prevails Over Jim Gilchrist
Again; Litigious Minuteman Founder Ordered to Pay Over $10,000 For
Subjecting Her to His Meritless Lawsuit.
Santa Ana, Calif. – November 19, 2008 – The Orange County Superior Court
today again rebuked litigious Minuteman founder Jim Gilchrist by ordering him to pay
Save Our State managing director Chelene Nightingale the sum of $10,426.88.
Judge Randell Wilkinson made the award against Gilchrist in order to reimburse
Nightingale for the attorneys’ fees and costs she incurred as a result of his meritless
lawsuit, which was previously stricken on October 15, 2008.
This latest ruling is one in a long string of legal defeats suffered by Gilchrist. In April
2008, Gilchrist and his associate Stephen J. Eichler filed nearly identical lawsuits
against a number of fellow anti-illegal immigration activists. These suits claimed that
Minutemen Marvin Stewart, Deborah Courtney and Paul Sielski, California Coalition
for Immigration Reform founder Barbara Coe, and Immigration Watchdog creator
Brook Young had "defamed" Gilchrist and Eichler by commenting on the turmoil and
legal battle within the Minuteman Project.
These ill-advised lawsuits have been repeatedly stricken, and the judgments against
Gilchrist and Eichler are mounting. Gilchrist was previously ordered to pay Stewart,
Courtney and Sielski the sum of $18,888.33, and Coe $9,100. The latest victory by
Nightingale brings the total to over $38,000.
Eichler, who claims to have a law degree and to host a Las Vegas radio show
boasting 1.5 million listeners, was also previously ordered to pay Minutemen
Courtney and Sielski the sum of $4,380.75. Nightingale will seek fees from Eichler
also.
"I am delighted to have represented Ms. Nightingale and vindicated her right to free
speech about issues of public concern," said attorney Daniel F. Lula. "No American
citizen should be cowed from speaking out about a prominent nonprofit entity like
the Minuteman Project, especially where there are allegations of internal turmoil and
misconduct. Ms. Nightingale did not deserve to be dragged into court, and today’s
award against Mr. Gilchrist is proof of that."
Unfortunately, it appears Gilchrist or those who support him are misrepresenting the
state of the legal cases on his website, www.minutemancc.us. A post there claims
that Eichler "won" his case on October 24, 2008, which is not the reality.
Save Our State is a California nonprofit corporation, working to educate the public
about the negative effects of illegal immigration.
===
Notice to SOS members: I, nor Joe Turner, nor A.G., ever collect any type of money for our own personal purposes. Save Our State has NEVER been an organization that sought tons of donations. Sometimes we asked for donations to cover expenses for events, etc...but we never pocketed any funds. This tradition continues today. Unfortunately I can not get the official court minutes posted here. (The pdf file is not transferring to text, however I have emailed the minutes to my list. If any member would like to view the minutes, please provide me via pm your email. However all court documents are public knowledge: http://www.occourts.org/)
The court minutes prove that neither Gilchrist nor Eichler lost due to their "public status". Like I stated above anti-SLAPP motions would NOT have been granted to cover our legal fees had we been guilty. The judges would have simply dismissed the cases due to their "public stature", but would not have rewarded any of us with legal costs...we would have been personally responsible.
The court minutes state that Gilchrist did NOT show actual malice! The minutes also state that neither Gilchrist nor Eichler showed burden of proof of ther (FALSE) claims. And in the Gilchrist minutes the judge even states that Gilchrist did not "even bother to sign his declarations".
It is highly unfortunate that some in the movement to save America put their trust and faith in the wrong individuals!!!
There will be no further postings by me on this subject. I believe the official court documents more than prove the TRUTH!!!!
I am NOT receiving any reward money - period! Save Our State is NOT receiving any reward money - period! Out-of-pocket expenses are being reimbursed and the legal fees are being covered - period!!
==
***- PDF files archive
These are the PDF files for the case. You can click on the attachments on this post to either save or open them.
Court_minutes_Gilchrist[1].pdf (366.9 KB, 0 views)
SOS-Chelene-Gilchrist Press_Release_Court_Ruling[1].pdf (78.1 KB, 0 views)
Stipulation_for_Gilchrist[1].pdf (12.8 KB, 1 views)
=
+++++END
=
